Two festive cakes, two different flavor paths
If you're deciding between David’s Cookies' Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake and the Carnival Cake, you're really choosing between two dessert personalities. The Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake leans rich and indulgent, while the Carnival Cake is bright, colorful, and vanilla-forward. Both are pre-cut into 14 slices and priced similarly, but the eating experience is quite different.
What each cake brings to the table
- Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake: Three layers of moist chocolate cake soaked with simple syrup alternate with two layers of chocolate chip edible cookie dough and two layers of marshmallow cream, iced with fudge frosting and finished with chocolate cake crumbs and a marshmallow border. This tells you the cake is built for chocolate lovers who want a mix of textures: moist cake, chewy cookie dough, and fluffy marshmallow.

Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake - Carnival Cake: The Carnival Cake features pink and blue 'cotton candy' swirled cake tiers, purple icing layers, and birthday cake edible sugar cookie dough with rainbow sprinkles, finished with white icing and a purple border. If you prefer vanilla and a playful, colorful presentation, this cake delivers a lighter flavor profile with a festive look.

Carnival Cake
Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake vs Carnival Cake
Here’s how the two cakes stack up on the details that matter most for your order.
- Base flavor: The Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake uses moist chocolate cake, while the Carnival Cake is a vanilla cake with cotton-candy swirls.
- Fillings: The chocolate chip cake layers chocolate chip edible cookie dough and marshmallow cream; the Carnival Cake layers birthday cake edible sugar cookie dough with rainbow sprinkles and purple icing.
- Frosting: Fudge frosting with a marshmallow border tops the chocolate chip cake; the Carnival Cake has pure white icing and a purple border.
- Look: The chocolate chip cake is finished with chocolate cake crumbs and chocolate chips; the Carnival Cake is pink, blue, and purple with rainbow sprinkles.
- Serving size: Both are pre-cut into 14 slices.
- Price: The Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake is USD 56.90; the Carnival Cake is USD 47.55.
Which cake should you order?
Choose the Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cake when your crowd craves deep chocolate and a gooey, marshmallow-filled center. It's a richer dessert that pairs well with coffee or milk. Choose the Carnival Cake when you want a celebration centerpiece that looks as festive as the occasion—its cotton-candy colors and rainbow sprinkles make it a hit at birthday parties or any event where visual wow matters.
Both cakes share the same convenient 14-slice format, so portion planning is identical. The price difference is modest, but the flavor difference is clear. If you're still torn, consider who you're serving: chocolate loyalists will appreciate the fudge and cookie dough, while those who prefer vanilla and a lighter finish will enjoy the Carnival Cake.


