Fresh Baked Assorted Cookies Tin - 2LB

The tin arrived with all 24 cookies intact, which surprised me since I've had boxes of baked goods show up as crumbs before. The peanut butter ones with the peanut butter chips are dangerously good, and the double chocolate chip stayed soft for days. Two pounds goes fast in this house.

The oatmeal raisin ones were the surprise favorite — soft, chewy, and you can actually taste the cinnamon. Twenty-four cookies at 1.5 oz each is a lot more generous than I expected for the price. Tin arrived with everything intact, not a single crumble.

I ordered this for a weekend get-together and the peanut butter ones with the chips disappeared first. The oatmeal raisin was the sleeper hit though, nice and chewy. 24 cookies in a 2lb tin felt like a fair amount for the price.